The Difference Between X-Ray and Ultrasound: Which Do You Need?

You have hurt your ankle, or perhaps you are feeling a nagging pain in your abdomen. You visit your doctor, and they hand you a requisition form for diagnostic imaging.

​

Sometimes they check the box for an X-Ray. Other times, they check the box for an Ultrasound. And occasionally, they check both.

​

For many patients, this can be confusing. Aren't they both just taking pictures of the inside of your body? While the goal is the same—to figure out what is causing your pain—the technology is completely different. It is like comparing a camera to a sonar system.

​

At Frontier Diagnostics in Guelph, we offer both modalities. Here is a simple guide to understanding the difference and why your doctor chose the one they did.

​

The X-Ray: The "Bone Specialist"

X-rays are the oldest and most common form of medical imaging. Think of an X-ray like a camera with a very specialized flash.

 

How it works: It sends a quick beam of energy (radiation) through your body to a detector on the other side. Your dense tissues, like bones, block the energy and show up clearly as white. Softer tissues, like muscle or organs, let the energy pass through and show up as shadows or grey areas. Air (like in your lungs) shows up black.

 

When do we use it? Because it is so good at seeing hard density, X-rays are the gold standard for:

• Fractures: Checking for broken bones.

• Arthritis: Looking at the spacing between joints.

• Chest Issues: Checking for pneumonia in the lungs.

• Foreign Objects: Seeing if you accidentally swallowed a coin or have metal in the body.

 

Is it safe? X-rays do use a very small amount of ionizing radiation. However, modern digital X-ray machines (like the ones we use at Frontier Diagnostics) use incredibly low doses—often just a fraction of the background radiation you are exposed to from the sun every year.

​

The Ultrasound: The "Soft Tissue Specialist"

If X-rays are cameras, Ultrasound is like bat sonar (echolocation). It uses absolutely no radiation.

 

How it works: The technologist places a probe on your skin with some warm gel. This probe sends high-frequency sound waves into your body. These sound waves bounce off your organs and fluids and return to the probe to create a real-time, moving image.

​

When do we use it? Sound waves travel beautifully through fluid and soft tissue but bounce right off bone. This makes ultrasound the perfect choice for:

• Abdominal Pain: Checking the liver, gallbladder, kidneys, and pancreas.

• Pregnancy: Monitoring the baby (fetus) without using radiation.

• Blood Flow: Checking for blood clots in the legs or examining the carotid arteries (as seen in our stroke screening).

• Muscles and Tendons: We can watch your muscles move in real-time to check for tears.

 

Is it safe? Yes. Because it uses sound waves rather than radiation, ultrasound is considered completely safe for everyone, including pregnant women and children.

​

Can I Just Ask for an Ultrasound Instead? 

We often hear patients ask if they can have an ultrasound instead of an X-ray to avoid radiation.

 

The answer is usually no, because they look at different things. If you have a suspected broken wrist, an ultrasound cannot see through the bone clearly enough to diagnose the fracture. Conversely, if you have gallstones, an X-ray beam will pass right through them, making them invisible.

 

Sometimes, your doctor will order both. For example, if you have shoulder pain, an X-ray checks the bones for arthritis, while an ultrasound checks the rotator cuff tendons for tears. They work together to give us the full picture.

 

Visit Frontier Diagnostics

Whether you need a walk-in X-ray or a scheduled ultrasound, our team is here to help. We use the latest digital technology to ensure your exam is quick, safe, and precise.

​

Located in Guelph, Ontario. Check our website for walk-in hours or call us to book your ultrasound appointment today.

​

​

This blog is for general information only and isn’t intended to be medical advice. Please consult a healthcare provider for any questions or concerns about your own health.